Daniel McCarthy (Heritage Foundation & Modern Age) joins Jon Harris to discuss the evolution of Republican foreign policy from Reagan to Trump, the defeat of Thomas Massie, and the tension between restraint, realism, and neoconservatism. A must-watch for conservatives wrestling with America’s role in the world today.
Topics include: Reagan’s peace through strength, Bush-era nation-building, Trump’s transactional approach, historical conservative thought (Washington, Calhoun, Taft), current challenges with Iran/Israel, and why Massie’s loss reveals deeper party realities.
0:00:12 – Welcome & Introduction to Daniel McCarthy
00:01:02 – Massie Defeat & Republican Foreign Policy Vacuum Post-Reagan
00:02:17 – Pre-Reagan Conservative Foreign Policy & Cold War Mindset
00:03:32 – Ronald Reagan’s “Peace Through Strength”
00:06:24 – Post-Cold War Shift: Bush Sr. to George W. Bush Neoconservatism
00:09:27 – Trump’s Break with Forever Wars & America First Realism
00:10:52 – Historical Conservative Restraint: Washington, Calhoun, Taft, Rand Paul
00:17:23 – Realism vs. Idealism: Iran, Israel, Nuclear Threats & Modern Dilemmas
00:28:57 – The Limits of “Fortress America” in a Global Economy
00:32:08 – Trump’s Transactional Approach vs. Neocon Romanticism
00:35:07 – Thomas Massie’s Defeat: Israel Lobby, Party Loyalty & Future of Anti-Zionism
00:42:44 – Where Does Anti-Zionism Fit — GOP or Democrats?
00:51:11 – Closing Thoughts & Where to Find Daniel McCarthy
Our Sponsors:
* Check out Mars Men and use my code Mengotomars.com for a great deal: https://mengotomars.com
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/conversations-that-matter8971/donations
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy